Meet our Faculty

Richard Allington
Principal
Dr. Richard Allington has previously taught at Saint Louis University, Rosati-Kain High School, Christendom College, Eastern New Mexico University, and also at JPII. He graduated from Christendom College where he experienced how an integrated classical curriculum guided by the Catholic faith can inspire students to pursue truth and beauty. He then studied Medieval History at Saint Louis University, focusing his research on the prayers and devotions of the crusaders. During this time he also taught Latin at JPII and was deeply impressed by the strong academic standards and supportive community he experienced at the school.
After graduating from SLU, he returned to Christendom College to teach for a year before taking a permanent position as part of the history faculty at Eastern New Mexico University. Married to a proud St. Louisian and with a deep love of the Catholic history, culture, and community in this region, Dr. Allington and his family always hoped to return to the St. Louis area and more specifically to JPII, and they are delighted to be here now.
Dr. Allington first came to JPII as a Latin teacher during the 2017-18 academic year while he was finishing his graduate program. He was impressed by the school’s strong Latin program, that still wins awards in the National Latin Exam each year, as well as the culture of mutual support among the faculty and the attitude of gratitude for faithful classical education practiced by the teachers, students, and parents.
Returning as Vice-Principal in 2023 and serving as Principal since 2024, Dr. Allington considers himself fortunate to have discovered still deeper and greater strengths of JPII. He especially loves our school’s unflinching fidelity to the teachings of the Catholic faith, the students’ desire to live out these teachings through lives centered on prayer and the sacraments, and the many beautiful acts of support through which JPII families practice charity to one another, creating a community built on love.
Dr. Allington is proud of his own background as a homeschooler and loves the way that JPII’s hybrid structure is pioneering a new model of education that honors the family as the chief source of love and wisdom in the life of a child, while providing students with opportunities to practice the cardinal and theological virtues in community with one another. He admires the zeal for faith and reason displayed by JPII students and alumni as they become capable and confident Catholic leaders ready to evangelize the world.
Email: [email protected]
About Dr Allington
Education:
- B.A. in History, Summa Cum Laude, Christendom College
- PhD in Medieval History, With Distinction, Saint Louis University
5 things Dr Allington loves about JPII
JPII’s unflinching fidelity to the teachings of the Magisterium of the Church means we are first and foremost a community of intentional Catholics striving together to live, protect, and defend the Faith.
… a model of education that honors the family as the chief source of love and wisdom in the life of a child, while providing students with opportunities to practice the cardinal and theological virtues in community with one another.
… school-wide attitude of gratitude for faithful classical education, the culture of mutual support among the faculty, and the teachers’ desire to model enthusiastic and authentic love of both spiritual and academic pursuits.
… the zeal for faith and reason displayed by JPII students and alumni as they become capable and confident Catholic leaders ready to evangelize the world. Students desire to live out Catholic teachings through lives centered on prayer and the sacraments
… the many beautiful acts of support through which JPII families practice charity to one another, creating a community built on love.
Administrative Team

Sebastian Garren
high school dean
Education:
- B.A. in Classical Languages, Philosophy, Medieval Studies from Wabash College
- Classical Civilization (Instituti per Studi Classici)
Experience: St. John Paul II Preparatory School, 2015 – present
Mr. Sebastian Garren graduated from Wabash College with a Major in Classics, and Minors in both Philosophy and Medieval Studies. He studied in Italy for a semester at the Institute of Classical Studies where he learned about the many brick-mortars of Ancient Rome and sat amongst enormous stacks of books in the prestigious American Academy Library, trying to decide whether Ancient Roman education had any redeeming qualities.
In college, he was elected president of the Newman Center, founded a theology magazine Unapologetic, and became editor-in-chief of the thorny student magazine The Wabash Commentary.
He won a Fulbright Scholarship to study education in Finland, where he languished for a sunny summer, eating thick vanilla ice cream woven with black licorice, while contemplating what school is like in Heaven.
Mr. Garren has had the pleasure of teaching at JPII for the past 9 years. As Dean he oversees the executive function of the high school including discipline, curriculum, the house system, teacher assistance, and parent resources. He has taught fourteen different courses and loves working with the students, teachers, and parents of the JPII community – whether it be on academic issues or preparing a surprise piñata party for the Principal.
An avid reader, he reads economics, folk tales, science fiction, history, and children’s books. Really everything except 19th century French novels, which he has an irrational prejudice against.

Anna Catalano
middle School dean
Education:
- B.A. in English Education summa cum laude, minor in Communication from Maryville University
Experience:
While at Maryville, Ms. Catalano completed several secondary education practicums at various public schools where she worked primarily with at risk students. She also worked as a university teacher’s assistant and tutor in the university’s writing center working with ESL students. Ms. Catalano began teaching at Saint John Paul II Preparatory School in the fall of 2014 and has loved every minute of it!
As a cradle Catholic, Ms. Catalano appreciates St. John Paul II Preparatory School’s strong Catholic identity and emphasis on virtue and character building. As a former homeschooler and graduate of Kolbe Academy, she enjoys teaching in a collegiate model school which encourages organizational and motivational skills in its students as well as close parental involvement.

Seana Tetzlaff
board president emeritus
Education:
- Coursework in Psychology from University of South Florida
- A.A. from Hillsborough Community College
- PK & K Teacher Certification, North American Montessori Center
Mrs. Tetzlaff has been privileged to be a part of JPII from the very beginning as one of the founding families. Over the last 9 years she has been involved as a board member, teacher and Dean. She has been married to her husband Marcus for 30 years and has a daughter Hailie, who is a 2013 JPII graduate.
Mrs. Tetzlaff worked in Atlanta in the public school system with autistic preschoolers and a private Catholic school as a kindergarten assistant and co-teacher. She worked at Gateway Academy as a temporary 2nd grade teacher, as a substitute teacher for grades PK through 6th grade, co-teacher for Pre-K and an assistant to first grade. After receiving her certification as a Preschool/Kindergarten teacher from North American Montessori Center, she began to implement a Montessori program for Pre-K until the school’s closing.
Mrs. Tetzlaff has a deep desire to share Christ with the children she teaches, support parents in their God given role as primary educators of their children and help form young people who know and love our Lord.
Office Staff

Stacey Roy
Office manager

Tara Schultz
office support, event coordinator, assistant to the deans

Elaine Swackhammer
Director of Admissions

Tammie Mushinski
Office Support

Kathleen Cupples
Accountant
Kathleen Cupples is the Business Manager for JPII, handling payroll and family accounts at both campuses. She has held this position since 2017. Kathleen has a Master of Social Work from Saint Louis University. She has been married for 23 years and has 6 children. Her oldest two children graduated from JPII and are currently in college, while the other four are current students.
Faculty – Upper School

Nathan Arends
Theology, History, science, latin, Logic
- M.A. in Theology, Aquinas Institute of Theology
- M.A. in Pastoral Studies, Aquinas Institute of Theology
- B.S. in Exercise Science, Truman State University

Todd Brown
latin, history
- M.A. in Theology, Augustine Institute
- M.A. in History, University of Missouri, St. Louis
- B.S. Business Management, University of Phoenix

Daniel Defonce
Theology, Economics
- Fellow, John Jay Institute
- B.S. Social Sciences | Missouri Baptist University

Lynn Dery
Theology, History, Public Speaking, Latin
- B.S. Physical Therapy, University of Wisconsin

Angela Field
History, Literature
- B.S. Legal Studies, University of Wisconsin Superior

Theresa Flores
Music
- B.M. in Music Theory and Minor in Child Psychology from the University of Missouri – St. Louis

Fr. Peter Fonseca
Bioethics, apologetics
- M.Div. from Kenrick Glennon Seminary
- M.A. Theology from Kenrick Glennon Seminary
- M.S. Biomedical Ethics from University of Mary
- B.A. Philosophy from Kenrick Glennon Seminary

Caroline Griesbauer
Mathematics, science
- B.S. in Chemistry from University of Dallas, Irving, TX
- B.A. in Theology from University of Dallas, Irving, TX

Robert Hochreiter
mathematics, Science
- AAS in Electronics Engineering Technology
- M.S. in Physics from University of New Hampshire, Durham, NH
- B.A. in Classical Liberal Arts from Magdalen College, Warner, NH

Jennifer Hogan
Philosophy, MAthematics, Science
-
BS, Biology and Philosophy, University of Scranton
-
MS, Biology, Northeastern University
-
MA, Christian Spirituality, Creighton University

Maggie Jackson
Art
-
Fine Arts Studies at Fontbonne University
-
Prince’s School of Traditional Arts
-
Currently apprenticing under Iconographer Aidan Hart

Anne Klein
Mathematics
- B.S. in Elementary Education summa cum laude from University of MIssouri-St. Louis

Hudson Levanos
history
- B.A. in History, University of Missouri, St. Louis
- M.A. in History, University of Missouri, St. Louis

Kimberly Lytle
Literature, History
- B.A. in English and Creative Writing, Creighton University
- M.A.T. with an emphasis in Communication and Literature, Webster University,

Laura Maxwell
Middle school aide

Robert Shea
latin
- Doctoral Studies in Medieval and Early Modern German Literature at University of Toronto, A.B.D.
- M.A. in German Studies from University of Missouri
- M.A. in English from Southeast Missouri State University
- B. A. in Political Science from University of Missouri

William Sullivan
History, Latin
- M. A. in Education from Kent State University, Kent, OH
- B. A. in English from Borromeo Seminary College in Wickliffe, OH
Faculty - Lower School

Karla Boyer
2nd Grade
- Business Administration – St. Louis Community College
- European Art History – St. Charles Community Colleg

Jo Ann Buckley
grade School aide

Patty Cahill
1st Grade

Julie Forbes
3rd Grade
- M.A. Elementary Education from Saint Michael’s College
- B.S. Natural Resources from University of Vermont

Mary Beth Franzen
4th grade
- B.A. in Elementary Education, Western Illinois University

Mary Kay Fulton
3rd Grade
- B.S. in Applied Computer Science from Illinois State University

Julie Harrell
1st grade
- B. A. in Business, Webster University

Angelena Hoeber
Grade school aide

Cheri Hoeber
Pre-Kindergarten

Marianna Hoeber
grade school art
- St. Charles Community College, Graphic Design
- Art Institute of Pittsburgh, Graphic Design and Concept Art

Charlie Kinnison
Music
- B.M.E. with emphasis in vocal music instruction from the University of Missouri – St. Louis
- K-12 General Music Certified
- Orff Schulwerk Level 1 Certification

Kelly Koschmeder
2nd grade
- B.A. in the liberal arts, University of Southern New Hampshire

Todd Brown
latin, history
- M.A. in Theology, Augustine Institute
- M.A. in History, University of Missouri, St. Louis
- B.S. Business Management | University of Phoenix

Elaine Maxwell
Kindergarten
- Coursework in Biology, Psychology, and Elder Care from Maryville University
- Degree from Healing Arts Center at St. Charles Community College

Lynette Schmitz
Principal Emeritus, 4th grade
- B.S. in Education in English/Language Arts Secondary Education magna cum laude from University of Missouri-St. Louis

Mary Sigillito
Pre-Kindergarten
- Florissant Valley Community College — Early Childhood
- Patricia Stevens Career College — Certificate
Veronica Wheadon
grade school aide